April 18 - May 3, 2026
After meeting at their daughters’ daycare, Ryan and Keith form an unlikely friendship, navigating fatherhood, loneliness, and the confounding terms of a mortgage loan. Through a blend of humor, empathy, and raw honesty, Hunter skillfully intertwines these two men’s stories, bridging the gap between their individual life experiences and shedding light on the complexities of human existence.
NY Drama Critics’ Circle Award – Best Play
“[A] must-see heartbreaker of a play.” —The New York Times
“A Case for the Existence of God finds what connects us all and holiness in humanity.” —The Observer
Synopsis
After meeting at their daughters’ daycare, Ryan and Keith form an unlikely friendship, navigating fatherhood, loneliness, and the confounding terms of a mortgage loan. Through a blend of humor, empathy, and raw honesty, Hunter skillfully intertwines these two men’s stories, bridging the gap between their individual life experiences and shedding light on the complexities of human existence.
NY Drama Critics’ Circle Award – Best Play
“[A] must-see heartbreaker of a play.” —The New York Times
“A Case for the Existence of God finds what connects us all and holiness in humanity.” —The Observer
Connect with Us
e-Newsletter